![]() |
| A bus franchising announcement in St Helen's in January |
The first tranche of Liverpool's newly franchised bus network went live a couple of weeks ago. It will soon be followed by the first tranches of franchised buses in West Yorkshire, and both South Yorkshire and the West Midlands shouldn't be far behind. Scotland, meanwhile, is planning to bring buses back under control (mainly through franchising, not full public control) by 2031, despite initially seeming to be more ahead of the game than this, having passed it's own Bus Services Act as long ago as 2019.
Bus company McGill's are furious about the Scotland decision, likening First Minister John Swinney to a dictator. While I'm pretty sure that neither Stagecoach nor Diamond called Andy Burnham a dictator when he was Mayor of Greater Manchester and was starting the process to bring in the Bee Network, they did force two judicial reviews on the decision and ran countless attack ads across bus sidings and social media so expect more of the same in Scotland.
The big worry the West Midlands seems to be having about franchising at the moment appears to be who will handle all the complaints from passengers when the system switches over. It seems to be dawning on them that it will probably be the council, and they seem genuinely horrified by the prospect if this story is anything to go on. Even as a glass half empty person myself, it seems very telling that the first thing the local authority is thinking about is how many complaints they're going to get about buses after franchising. I mean, yeah, they will but... bigger picture and all that?
Another issue that goes hand in hand with franchising as it is rolled out increasingly widely is the under representation of small and medium sized bus companies when contracts are handed out. In Greater Manchester, the Bee Network was handed over to a small group of large bus companies, specifically Stagecoach, Arriva, Go North West, Metroline, Diamond. This pattern of handing the contracts to the same large companies who have been making passengers lives a misery for years has also been followed in Liverpool and West Yorkshire, and trade publisher RouteOne has published an opinion piece this week about the dangers of excluding small and medium sized businesses from contracts in the newly franchised bus networks. On one hand, no one wants to hand a franchised bus contract to a company that will go bust in 12 months time (hello Little Gem...) but on the other hand, if you have a small operator that is doing a good job on a route you intend to keep anyway, why give the contract to someone else who might not do as good a job? The decision to remove the 385 route from D&G and hand it to Diamond springs to mind (again...)
The 2025 England and Wales Bus Services Act included a new provision for councils, city regions and mayoral authorities to set up their own publicly owned bus companies for the first time since 1986, a reversal of de-regulation that campaigners have been fighting for for a very long time. In late September, Mayor of London Sadiq Khan announced plans for the capital to have its own publicly owned bus company as part of a wider series of changes to TfL. Given that London was the only part of the UK not to see it's buses de-regulated in 1986, and given the parlous financial state most councils in England and Wales currently find themselves in, it perhaps isn't surprising that the capital is leading the way when it comes to this particular bit of bus reform.
At a national level, the recent announcement that there are plans to crack down on 'loudcasting' on buses is welcome, but feels largely unenforceable in reality. There are systems in place, via the live chat function on the Bee Network app, to discreetly report antisocial and distressing behaviour on Bee Network buses already, but I don't know to what extend people are using it or how consoling or effective the outcomes are when the facility is used.
The focus on 'loudcasting' also fails to recognise the sheer variety of noise pollution on public transport. Music is an obvious example of noise pollution on buses and trains but the announcement fails to recognise the sheer annoyance caused by the following:
The playing of podcasts on buses (especially right wing conspiracy theory flavoured ones)
The playing of football commentary during big sporting events
and, my pet peeve:
The repeated playing of the same short social media clip over and over again as though the person with the phone in question is a toddler with the attention span of a sesame seed, not an adult. The other variation of this is people flicking from sound clip to sound clip, a sort of aural infinite scroll, that everyone else on the bus is then subjected to because the scroller is bored and can't settle on any one particular thing to entertain themselves with, or, indeed, do it quietly.
There's also noise pollution that falls into the annoying-but-understandable category, namely the playing of nursery rhymes to pacify fretful babies who have previously been howling the place down.
In that case, if it's a choice between listening to the wheels on the bus go round and round or baa baa black sheep or listening to a howling baby, I think many of us would take the nursery rhymes.
On the music front, as a veteran of late night and long distance commuting on the 192, I tended to find that certain musical genres annoyed me more than others. The volume at which the music was being played was also a contributory factor. To give an example, happy hardcore played at any volume is annoying but it was almost always played at ear splitting volume. Bhangra, on the other hand, is a less annoying musical genre to me personally and it usually tended to be played more quietly when traversing the A6 late at night than the happy hardcore inevitably was. Readers will no doubt have their own equivalents.







