Saturday, October 24, 2026

The Future of Bus Franchising, part 2

A bus franchising announcement in St Helen's in January

The first tranche of Liverpool's newly franchised bus network went live a couple of weeks ago. It will soon be followed by the first tranches of franchised buses in West Yorkshire, and both South Yorkshire and the West Midlands shouldn't be far behind. Scotland, meanwhile, is planning to bring buses back under control (mainly through franchising, not full public control) by 2031, despite initially seeming to be more ahead of the game than this, having passed it's own Bus Services Act as long ago as 2019. 

Bus company McGill's are furious about the Scotland decision, likening First Minister John Swinney to a dictator. While I'm pretty sure that neither Stagecoach nor Diamond called Andy Burnham a dictator when he was Mayor of Greater Manchester and was starting the process to bring in the Bee Network, they did force two judicial reviews on the decision and ran countless attack ads across bus sidings and social media so expect more of the same in Scotland.

The big worry the West Midlands seems to be having about franchising at the moment appears to be who will handle all the complaints from passengers when the system switches over. It seems to be dawning on them that it will probably be the council, and they seem genuinely horrified by the prospect if this story is anything to go on. Even as a glass half empty person myself, it seems very telling that the first thing the local authority is thinking about is how many complaints they're going to get about buses after franchising. I mean, yeah, they will but... bigger picture and all that?

Another issue that goes hand in hand with franchising as it is rolled out increasingly widely is the under representation of small and medium sized bus companies when contracts are handed out. In Greater Manchester, the Bee Network was handed over to a small group of large bus companies, specifically Stagecoach, Arriva, Go North West, Metroline, Diamond. This pattern of handing the contracts to the same large companies who have been making passengers lives a misery for years has also been followed in Liverpool and West Yorkshire, and trade publisher RouteOne has published an opinion piece this week about the dangers of excluding small and medium sized businesses from contracts in the newly franchised bus networks. On one hand, no one wants to hand a franchised bus contract to a company that will go bust in 12 months time (hello Little Gem...) but on the other hand, if you have a small operator that is doing a good job on a route you intend to keep anyway, why give the contract to someone else who might not do as good a job? The decision to remove the 385 route from D&G and hand it to Diamond springs to mind (again...)

The 2025 England and Wales Bus Services Act included a new provision for councils, city regions and mayoral authorities to set up their own publicly owned bus companies for the first time since 1986, a reversal of de-regulation that campaigners have been fighting for for a very long time. In late September, Mayor of London Sadiq Khan announced plans for the capital to have its own publicly owned bus company as part of a wider series of changes to TfL. Given that London was the only part of the UK not to see it's buses de-regulated in 1986, and given the parlous financial state most councils in England and Wales currently find themselves in, it perhaps isn't surprising that the capital is leading the way when it comes to this particular bit of bus reform.

At a national level, the recent announcement that there are plans to crack down on 'loudcasting' on buses is welcome, but feels largely unenforceable in reality. There are systems in place, via the live chat function on the Bee Network app, to discreetly report antisocial and distressing behaviour on Bee Network buses already, but I don't know to what extend people are using it or how consoling or effective the outcomes are when the facility is used. 

The focus on 'loudcasting' also fails to recognise the sheer variety of noise pollution on public transport. Music is an obvious example of noise pollution on buses and trains but the announcement fails to recognise the sheer annoyance caused by the following:

The playing of podcasts on buses (especially right wing conspiracy theory flavoured ones)

The playing of football commentary during big sporting events

and, my pet peeve:

The repeated playing of the same short social media clip over and over again as though the person with the phone in question is a toddler with the attention span of a sesame seed, not an adult. The other variation of this is people flicking from sound clip to sound clip, a sort of aural infinite scroll, that everyone else on the bus is then subjected to because the scroller is bored and can't settle on any one particular thing to entertain themselves with, or, indeed, do it quietly. 

There's also noise pollution that falls into the annoying-but-understandable category, namely the playing of nursery rhymes to pacify fretful babies who have previously been howling the place down. 

In that case, if it's a choice between listening to the wheels on the bus go round and round or baa baa black sheep or listening to a howling baby, I think many of us would take the nursery rhymes.

On the music front, as a veteran of late night and long distance commuting on the 192, I tended to find that certain musical genres annoyed me more than others. The volume at which the music was being played was also a contributory factor. To give an example, happy hardcore played at any volume is annoying but it was almost always played at ear splitting volume. Bhangra, on the other hand, is a less annoying musical genre to me personally and it usually tended to be played more quietly when traversing the A6 late at night than the happy hardcore inevitably was. Readers will no doubt have their own equivalents. 



Saturday, January 10, 2026

The future of bus franchising


The Local Government Chronicle have published an informative and detailed article about the future of bus franchising across the UK. At the time of writing, Greater Manchester's Bee Network is the only franchised bus service outside of London but - as the article reveals - it won't be for long as Liverpool, South Yorkshire, West Yorkshire, Cambridgeshire & Peterborough, the West Midlands and the North East all plan to follow suit in the coming years. 

The article also gives a good overview of recent changes to the law since the Bus Services Act 2017, which is the legislation the GMCA had to use in order to get the Bee Network up and running. 

Much has changed since then, as the article reveals. 

Sunday, January 4, 2026

One year of the Bee Network


The 5th of January 2026 marks one year since all ten Greater Manchester local authorities joined the Bee Network. While there have been a number of interesting ideas, innovations and improvements, there is still a lot of work to be done if TfGM and GMCA genuinely want to encourage people to use the buses, and to give bus users a decent experience.

Here are some thoughts on how it's been going over the past 12 months. Firstly, the bad news...

There is a sense of complacency at big companies who have kept most of the routes they were running, pre Bee Network:

Many routes are still being run by companies who were running them pre-Bee Network, and they often weren't running them that well. This has continued into the Bee Network era with companies such as Stagecoach returning to bad habits like pulling buses that are running late and stranding passengers at bus stops. Passengers only find out this has happened when the bus they are waiting for never turns up and disappears off the app without any explanation. 

The binning buses phenomenon is often tied to traffic congestion (which I'll talk about in a bit) but it really doesn't help to encourage bus use because, if it happens on a regular basis on the same route (the 383 for example) then it just puts you off using that route. 

Capacity and overcrowding

Capacity has been reduced across the smallest sized buses (ie the yellow Tiny Buses) as they are smaller than their pre-Bee Network alternatives. This is having an impact on overcrowding at peak times (during the morning and afternoon school runs and rush hours) which, even without the impact of smaller buses, is no better than previously, in fact it's sometimes worse. 

More judicious use of the tiny buses (ie not using them at times when routes are guaranteed to be at their busiest) and expanded timetables to include extra buses at peak times on busy routes, would help to alleviate both problems. I type this as someone who has had the 385 drive past them during the evening rush hour because the bus was too small to accommodate the number of of passengers needing to get on, meaning it was full before it had completed even a third of its route. 

Reliability

Some buses are less reliable than previously, for example the 385, which changed provider from D&G to Diamond under the Bee Network. This went from a pretty solid, friendly, reliable service under D&G to a thoroughly unreliable one under Diamond. I suspect that there will be other examples of this. 

Scrapped routes

As I wrote at the time, I thoroughly understand and support TfGM's decision to bin off the 375 given that it was basically a ghost bus that the operator was milking for the subsidy, but... That doesn't mean that Marple and Bosden Farm don't need transport links to Hazel Grove and Stepping Hill Hospital. At the moment both communities are almost entirely cut off from their neighbouring borough and local hospital. Which is insane. 

A solution would be to design a new route that takes in Marple, Bosden Farm, Hazel Grove, Stepping Hill and possibly Bramhall (which is not well served for buses). It would also need to be a more frequent service than the 375, which wouldn't be hard as the 375 was only every 2 hours most of the time and, sometimes, it was only every 4 hours. Similarly, it would need to be reliable and actually turn up which was also a problem with the 375. It would also be useful if the timetable fitted in with visiting times at Stepping Hill Hospital. 

High Frequency Buses

High frequency buses are a joke and don't exist for the majority of travellers in Greater Manchester. In fact, there is a direct correlation between those routes which are high frequency buses and those which were the biggest cash cows for bus companies, pre Bee Network. A classic example of this would be the 192, which had at least three bus wars fought over it during the 1990s and 2000's, a series of wars that only ended when Stagecoach's rivals, UK North, were stripped of a licence to operate. High frequency buses need to be designed and determined based on need, not on what happened after deregulation in 1986.

The Bee Network app

While the Bee Network app is useful and includes real time travel information, it's best used in situations where you're travelling home using a route you aren't familiar with and where you just want to quickly see when the next bus is due.

It isn't reliable enough to be used to make complex decisions about which bus to get.

If it's a choice between deciding which bus to catch at which stop based on the app, or walking a longer distance to get to a stop that all the local buses stop at, you're much better off taking the longer walk to the stop all the local buses stop at. 

Road congestion

There are some problems that TfGM, GMCA and the Bee Network cannot change. Needless to say, at peak times, it can often be quicker and easier to walk long distances than to wait for buses that clearly are not coming. 

There might be things that can be done to alleviate this in the grander sense. For example, Stockport Council have an ongoing consultation about one of the more epic pinch points on Marple Road and how they might make things a bit better, but without good leadership and genuinely helpful and workable policy at a national government and local government level then it's unlikely that our roads will get any better any time soon. 

Bus stops are frequently inaccessible thanks to car drivers

While the implementation of accessible buses with drop floors (except on the Tiny Buses alas, where the driver still has to get out of their seat and flip the ramp down), greater space for wheelchairs (again, except on the Tiny Buses) and visual and audio stop display information mark a distinct improvement for those with disabilities, there have been problems.

Specifically, a lack of road markings at bus stops and a tendency for local residents to use these stops as car parks coupled with the sense that any bus stop next to a shop is also fair game for drivers, often leads to buses being unable to stop at the bus stop and instead having to stop just down from it or, worse case scenario (and this does happen), simply open their doors in the middle of the road. To say this undermines accessible access would be an understatement. 

The bus stops on Nangreave Road on the 385 route, the bus stop next to Lentils & Lather on Marple Road in Marple, and the bus stop next to Premier on Dialstone Lane in Offerton are all notoriously bad for being clogged up and inaccessible thanks to cars. 

Bus shelters, where they exist, are often in a poor state of repair

I am thinking of the one at the junction of Lisburne Lane and Marple Road, heading towards Marple, which had a massive hole in the roof just before Christmas. Using that bus stop in torrential rain was not fun. In a related note, there are a number of bus stops I've used that have lights fitted which aren't working. Which is similarly fun when it's dark. 

Cross boundary travel related issues

Cross boundary routes appear to be equally if not more vulnerable under the Bee Network:  For example, there is now no bus at all between Stockport and Macclesfield and commuters between the two towns are left entirely at the mercy of Northern Trains: Not a happy prospect. The only other way to get to Macclesfield from Stockport would be to get in a car and join the daily gridlock along the A6 and Silk Road, then the bun fight for a parking space in Macclesfield itself. Good luck with that. 

Concessionary travel issues

While it's great to see the Bee Network and TfGM scrapping the 9:30am start for the retired persons bus pass, there remain issues around other types of concessionary travel. 

Some of these issues are national issues, but some have a local aspect to them, and as we have seen with the scrapping of the 9:30am rule, just because it's a local issue doesn't mean something can't be done locally.

There has been a number of local campaigns throughout the UK for children under 16 to receive free bus travel, which they currently don't get. Many are not even guaranteed free bus travel to school. There's a much undersigned petition demanding free bus travel for under 16's, which you might want to consider signing. 

More recently, there has also been a campaign to provide free travel to school for those whose families have been made homeless and who are living in temporary accommodation, far away from their previous schools. 

Less known about are issues faced by those aged 16-19 who are travelling to sixth form college within Greater Manchester but from outside of the Greater Manchester area.  This will be a trickier issue to resolve than the other two issues, but it is one that is worth looking at if only because the current system has, accidentally, led to some howling inequalities for a small number of college students. 

I suspect that money will be the main barrier to change in each of these areas, but I remain hopeful nonetheless.

Good stuff

As well as the incoming scrapping of the 9:30am start for retired persons bus pass, meaning that pensioners (from March 2026) will no longer have to pay to travel before 9:30am and will be able to attend medical and hospital appointments without having to worry about being able to afford the travel costs, we have also seen the very welcome return of the annual any bus pass. This is a really good thing because it means that you can save money on your cost of travel across the year by buying your ticket at the start of the year. By buying your ticket at the start of the year you also have the satisfaction of knowing you're covered for 12 months and don't have to buy a new ticket every month. There's also the new option of buying the (admittedly very expensive) annual ticket in instalments via a credit union. A nice innovation and a good idea.  

In other good news, new contracts for drivers now mean that a driver from one company can move to a different company operating within the Bee Network without having to start again at the new company on the basic salary. 

I am also, personally, very pleased about the wider introduction of audio and visual stop announcements which, while provided for accessibility reasons, are essential when travelling in the dark.

While the introduction of the Bee Network across Greater Manchester is rightly being hailed as a triumph, there are still improvements to be made.

At a basic level, there should be a baseline standard of training for drivers that all operators operating under the Bee Network sign up to and stick to. This would hopefully avoid drivers being sent out on buses who are woefully ill equipped in terms of knowing the route and how to operate equipment. It would also hopefully reduce the risk of drivers getting lost or having to ask for directions from passengers when driving their routes. 

There should also be a baseline standard of service that all operators operating under the Bee Network sign up to and stick to in terms of providing a credible, reliable and prompt service using vehicles that are fit for purpose. This would hopefully reduce the risk of services running more than 10 minutes late on a regular basis (I am looking at you 385...) and drivers turning up in vehicles that look like converted ambulances (admittedly, this has only happened once...).

I had thought that both of these things would be happening anyway but bitter experience over the past 12 months suggests it's not always the case.





Sunday, December 21, 2025

An interesting take on this years bus strikes and a Kafka esque nightmare for one Metrolink passenger


The Mancunian
, the University of Manchester student newspaper, has published an extensive and thoughtful piece about this years bus driver strikes. It handily situates the issues raised by drivers in a pre-Bee Network and post-Bee Network context, while also providing a student focused insight as to how the bus strikes impacted them. It is well worth a read. 

In other news, a disabled Metrolink passenger has been experiencing a Kafka esque nightmare with his ticket and travel arrangements, as documented in excruciating detail in both the MEN and Manchester World. 

Saturday, November 22, 2025

Return of the Super Stop


After experiencing the commute from hell on Tuesday night, I decided that things have got so bad with all the Marple buses that the only thing for it was to return to using the Super Stop.

Regular readers might recall me writing about Super Stops earlier in the year. For those of you who didn't read that post, a Super Stop is a bus stop that all of the buses I can use to get home stops at. 

To give you a flavour of why this seemed a good idea, let me give you an overview as to how it's gone with yo-yoing between bus stops and using the app over the past week or so versus the Super Stop app free experience.

Firstly, a typical experience with the app:

1) Leave work at 4pm

2) 10-15 minute walk to bus stop. Decision needs to be made at this point as to whether to put my money on the 385 or the 383, which go from different bus stops located 5 minutes apart.

3) Commit to 385 bus stop on the basis that the app says it's due at 4:35pm and the 383 at 4:25pm is often late anyway, and always packed.

4) Get to 4:30pm and check the app again. It now says that the 385 isn't coming until 4:45pm, but that's OK because the next 383 isn't until 4:43 anyway. 

5) Get to 4:40pm and check the app again. It now says that the 385 isn't coming until 4:50pm. Start to get worried.

6) Get to 4:45pm and check app again. 385 has now disappeared off app entirely and the only information available is for the 383, 384 or the 385 that's due at 5:37pm.

7) Decide to wait at stop anyway: The 385 has turned up after it's disappeared off the app previously.

8) 5pm. 385 turns up, nearly drives past me. Consider jumping in road to make it stop but instead wave arms frantically until it stops.

There is an alternate version where I opt for the 383 with similar results, but we'll skip that one.

The day the Bee Network can to Weatherfield

Instead, here is the Super Stop version of my commute:

1) Leave work at 4pm.

2) Walk 30 minutes to Super Stop.

3) 383 turns up at 3:35pm. Absolutely rammed. Opt not to get on as the 385 is timetabled to arrive anytime now and there's another (usually less busy) 383 at 4:50pm.

4) Wait. Check watch periodically.

5) It gets to 4:55pm: No other bus has arrived. Woman and child sharing bus stop with look worried.

6) 5pm. Clearly Stagecoach cannot be arsed running the 383 at 4:50pm tonight.

7) 5:09pm: The 385 arrives. Over 30 minutes late.


OK, the outcome is much the same in both cases, but... The Super Stop provides the security of giving me the option to get on the first bus that arrives (even though I didn't in this case) and saves me having to switch stops every time I think a bus isn't coming. It also stops me getting rain on my phone, leading to condensation in the morning when I head out again. 

So, things being as they are at the moment, it's a resounding win for the Super Stop over the app. 


Friday, November 21, 2025

The unexpected case for audio visual stop announcements


When audio visual stop announcements began to be introduced on Stagecoach buses ahead of Stockport joining the Bee Network, not everyone was impressed. Passengers could often be heard grumbling and taking the piss out of them and drivers would often not switch them on.

While the intention was always to make buses more accessible to those with visual and hearing impairments and other disabilities, I have stumbled across another reason for having them in recent weeks.

In short, they mean that I can figure out where the hell on Marple Road I am when travelling at night. 

Services such as the 358, 383 and 385 travel through some pretty remote, sparsely populated and landmark free areas that also tend to be very badly lit. When you're travelling in what looks out of the window to be complete darkness then one tree can look very like another and it can be nye on impossible to know which stop you've just gone past if there are no obvious landmarks visible to anchor it. Things like signs for the local cattery or the house with the dog statues outside tend to be meaningless after dark and you become increasingly thankful for things like petrol stations and curry houses with neon signage. 

How much of a relief is it then when you find yourself on a bus that actually tells you in real time where you are and which stop is coming up next.  

Sadly many of the buses are old and do not come with stop announcements. And sometimes, on the ones that do have it built in, the driver doesn't switch them on. 

Meaning that I am always, and increasingly, grateful whenever I encounter a bus that has them.

Wednesday, November 19, 2025

Everything Awful All At Once: When everything goes to shit, including the bloody app


Following on from my last post, I can see now that I was being overly optimistic about the powers of the Bee Network app.

The problem, as with all technology, is that it's only as good as the information you feed it. And, lately, it seems to be being fed the data equivalent of a highly processed burger and skinny fries with negligible percentage of potatoes.

The evening commute will start well enough: The app will say that one bus is running 10 minutes late, another is on time and will arrive 5 minutes after the late one. "Right" you think, "I'll wait for the one that is running 10 minutes late." 

You wait.

And wait.

And wait.

You check the app: The bus you are waiting at the stop for is now running 20 minutes late, but the other one is now running 15 minutes late so they'll probably arrive around the same time still. No need to change bus stops then.

Then, one or both of the buses disappears off the app entirely. And neither of them appear to have arrived.

I've been experiencing a lot of evening commutes like this over the past week or so. 

To provide some context, the 385 has been consistently running at least 20 minutes late pretty much every weekday evening for at least a fortnight now. Sometimes it's been over 30 minutes late. By which time it's disappeared off the app and you don't have a clue whether it's still coming or not.

It failed to arrive this morning as well, meaning that I was late for work because I had to get the 358 and double back on myself. 

To top it all, the 383 has also been running at least 10 minutes late most nights for at least a fortnight as well. And there's been similar problems tracking that on the app.

Other problems with the app include the following:

  • It gets confused as to which side of the road you're on.
  • If you're in a busy area with several bus stops (such as Stockport College) it gets confused about which stop you're at and floods you with too many stops and buses, making for a lot of scrolling before you can find the right info.
  • If the bus you're waiting for is late, it doesn't show the late bus at the top of the page but the next one that's due on the timetable instead, meaning you have to scroll down to find it.

The fact that it removes late buses that are actually still coming from the app is the worst though.

Over the past week there has been flooding and horrendous gridlock so it's not surprising that services have been running late. I also think that timetables need adjusting to account for the reality of gridlock on Marple Road, but I daresay that will never happen.

Friends travelling around other bits of Stockport have been experiencing similar issues with their own buses and also with the app, suggesting wider issues with the Bee Network itself. 

As for myself, I feel it is time for the return of the Super Stop.